You are here:   Catherine Hakim > ONLINE ONLY: Dust Busting Today's Gender Myths
 

What's more, in her recent paper "Feminist Myths and Magic Medicine", Hakim claims that the last Labour government's work policies were in fact counterproductive for gender equality. Encouraging part-time work may have increased the number of women employed, but ultimately, it only depresses women's long-term earning potential, as women take up lower-skilled, lower-paid positions, which outlaws them from the many professions in which long and dedicated hours are a prerequisite for success, and for which high salaries are the reward. At the same time, the burden on men to bread-win is only compounded. 

So if helping women to a work-life balance is currently still pricing them out of the competitive jobs market, how can we stop it from being a lacklustre compromise, the fatalistic result of choosing to have children? Nick Clegg's recent proposal for increased paternity leave, a potential solution, was about as popular as the offer of a flaccid pig's bladder. Which tells you a lot about how poorly part-time work is regarded by both men and business, and how resistant to change so many apparently accommodating fellows are when presented with hitherto "ladies only" options. The papers were awash with pointed examples of men who had jacked it all in to bring up baby, but the reality is that there is no househusband revolution on its way soon. Gender stereotypes aside, in the current economic climate, no one can afford it. Or at least, that's the get-out-of-playpen card for countless reluctant fathers.

But economics need not hamper equality: there is a cheap and cheerful (depending on which side of the Hoover you're standing on) alternative. If so many women work part-time in order to balance home and work life, why not just increase male participation in domestic duties? So simple, so often said, yet still not taken up. According to the National Office for Statistics 2005 Time Use survey, women spend an average of 20 minutes longer than men on both paid and domestic work per day, regardless of their occupation and the number of hours worked. While it seems sensible for anyone who works part-time to do more at home, professional full-timers suffer from a "hyper-homemaker" guilt, which finds them taking on the bulk of domestic duties, lest their male partners are "emasculated" by their success. Surely this cannot be some kind of biological compulsion at work; nature's way of keeping us in our place, lest women stretch their feeble, feminine, mental muscles and get so distracted evaluating the flaws in Aristotle's theory of justice, they forget to put the washing on. What intelligent working woman genuinely believes that saying no to late-night ironing equals child abuse, or spouse neglect? Whatever happened to simply — and very reasonably — asking a male partner to give a helping hand? Is it that more men than we thought are essentially lazy, chauvinistic anti-dishwashers? Or have so many women been brainwashed by the legacy of that boy-girl miscommunicative bible, "Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus", that they've forgotten that sentient, grown men can be asked to do things sometimes, and that, sometimes, men even do what they are asked. Besides, if reasonable communication does fail, even a total Neanderthal cannot fail to recognise the power of the cooking/cleaning/canoodling strike.

So while domestic burden may be at the root of the gender pay gap in Britain, it's really a luxury to be able to wrangle over household chores. Which makes it worth considering for whom International Women's Day is vitally important. All those females who will be subjected to culturally sanctioned rape within marriage today, to infibulation, to violent abuse. All those who will be deprived of education, healthcare, basic pay, or who will be simply treated as second best because of misfortune of birth. We, in the lucky West, owe it to them to refuse to be victims of feminism, or a latent sexism that is long overdue a push out of the double bed. A little duster redistribution is the least we can do.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
jarkin
September 29th, 2011
11:09 AM
This is a great article and I really agree with all that is in it, I was trained from an early age to Dust,Dyson and clean bathrooms by a mother who was one of those ladies that looking back was frustrated at living under male "suppression" of both her father originally and then her husband my father A Father who seriously once suggested that i could, if staying over with work ask " one of the girls" to do some of my ironing. However I now work for a woman and have women work for me and I am proud that I see no pay differences that are gender driven within our sphere of influence. I know this is far from universal so is the root cause of this happy position a gender balance in the workplace, positive awareness etc etc or in some small way is it the training I received 40 odd years ago with a tin of pledge and a duster ?? My Mum may well be looking on happy .

john
July 12th, 2011
9:07 AM
im a 23 y/o American male and im noticing that many of my peers with parents under 50(best differentiation ive found so far)have no idea how to cook or clean regardless of gender. I've also grown up noticing that Girl Power and the belief that men are inherently bad at certain things like cleaning/being a decent human is really screwing with a generation of males and producing females who believe they are princesses but act like Lilly allen. of course they are beyond reproach by any man because they grew up learning he is emotionally inferior and he is only trying to control her. so maybe a girl with morals steps in, but they seem to be about as rare as a guy with morals. we are 2 sides of an identical coin. its time for a new movement that encourages peace and equality not one side at the expense of the other. if we put as much effort into teaching kids to take the other persons shoes mentally and figure out the cause of their feelings rather than being creatures ready to fly off the handle at any moment we might create a better world for all.

witwoud
April 27th, 2011
1:04 PM
Excellent. More nagging. I'm sure that'll solve everything.

Nutkin
March 18th, 2011
4:03 PM
A well written article with the exception of one vital point: TRAINING. Ladies, breed and work as much as you wish. Please stop complaining and start introducing your man to the art of domestic science. He is more than able to wash a dish, iron a shirt and, God forbid, clean the bathroom! You only have yourselves to blame for poor training. Don't fall for the age old trick of him doing a poor job, so as not to be asked again. Drag them from their sheds, dens and working men's clubs and put them to use while you put your feet up. Now that's equality!

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.