You are here:   Blogs >Focus on Islamism > Hooligans, Racists, Bigots: We Don’t Want Your Help
Standpoint Blogs
 
 
Focus on Islamism
Wednesday 16th September 2009
Hooligans, Racists, Bigots: We Don’t Want Your Help

BY ALEXANDER MELEAGROU-HITCHENS

The recent emergence of the English Defence League (EDL) is the inevitable outcome of the failure of a government to properly address Islamic extremism topped off with good old fashioned British hooliganism and bigotry.  The involvement of groups like the EDL in working against Islamic extremism serves to give ammunition to those who already claim that all anti-Islamists are racists at heart.

My co-blogger, Michael Burleigh, claimed yesterday that the English Defence League had no demonstrable connections with the British National Party.  I would have to disagree with this, as I am aware of at least two. Firstly, as revealed by the Times, the EDL's web designer is none other than Chris Renton, who also acts as the BNP's ‘web guy'.  The indispensable Searchlight Magazine have also identified another BNP member at the heart of EDL operations, Davy Cooling, who they claim is an activist for the EDL's Luton wing. Despite this, the EDL insist they do not support the BNP and are not a racist organisation.  It is also important to consider at this point that two of the country's nastiest racist groups were present at the EDL demonstrations in Luton.  According to the Blood and Honour (a UK neo-Nazi group formed in the 1980s) online forum, a number of its members attended the EDL's Luton protests (screen shots of this closed forum are in my possession) and Searchlight make the claim that a member of the National Front had also attended.

Although unlikely, the EDL's rejection of accusations of racism and BNP support may be genuine (it is difficult to prove this beyond any doubt), but charges levelled at them as being anti-Muslim bigots will be far more difficult to swat away.  In a recent interview (45 seconds into the below video - try your best to ignore terror apologist Salma Yaqoob) with talkSport radio, EDL spokesman Paul Ray admitted that they are not only protesting against Islamic extremists, but in fact the EDL's beef is with ‘all devout Muslims'.  Similarly the BNP's Nick Griffin has also made accusations that all Muslims who devoutly follow their religion are by definition a threat to this country and Europe.

Incidentally, EDL spokesman Paul Ray is also the pro BNP blogger known as Lionheart.

This is no way to approach a very serious issue, and in fact makes the job of liberals who do recognise the problem many times harder.  As it stands, and with only a handful of notable exceptions, the subject of Islamic extremism is only being properly dealt with by people and organisations considered to be ‘right wing'.  It therefore becomes all too easy for those who (somehow unashamedly) call themselves part of the left and have allied with Islamists, to accuse people of being far right racists if they dare to identify Islamism as a problematic ideology (at a recent Stop the War Coalition event Lindsey German made this very accusation).  The recent adoption of the cause against Islamic extremism by the far right simply feeds into already established perceptions of anti-Islamists that exist among Islamists and their apologists, and allows their scurrilous accusations to be taken mildly seriously.

Whereas progressives are able to make the distinction between a devout Muslim and an extremist or an Islamist, the BNP and EDL insist on the rather patronising assumption that whether a practicing Muslim likes it or not, they are an extremist.  This is based on a very simplistic understanding of the core texts of Islam which discounts 1400 years of interpretation and scholarship and ignores the possibility that, rather than forever seeking to convert or kill all of us, the vast majority of Muslims follow their faith in a private and personal manner. 

Within the world of anti-jihadism, there is a clear divide between those who consider all Muslims to be a threat and those who understand that the problem lies within a small but very influential section of the Islamic world.  Siding with the former should not be an option as it requires a total disavowal and abandonment of liberal and pluralist values based solely on the basis of a mutual foe.

[email protected] 

 
Like this article? Share, save or print using the icons below
Delicious   Digg   StumbleUpon   Propeller   Reddit   Magnoliacom   Newsvine   Furl   Facebook   Google   Yahoo   Technorati   Icerocket   Print   Mail   Twitter   
Share/Save
 
 
 
Anonymous
October 13th, 2009
3:10 AM
Dear Sir, You may be interested in my Wiki-Skit on Salma Yaqoob, leader of Respect and champion of Unite Against Fascism: http://islamthefarleftandmisc.blogspot.com/ Yours, Paul Murphy. Birmingham.

NJM
September 16th, 2009
3:09 PM
Steve, Alex's post is exactly right. Salma Yaqoob is an on-the-record supporter of the so-called "resistance" in Iraq, Afghanistan & is an open supporter of homicide-bombers against Israel. These are simple facts, which you can look up for yourself. She has openly defended them, supported them & praised their barbaric violence (just like most of the idiots in the Respect Coalition & the StWC). It's not a "cheap shot" - it's a statement of fact. And nowhere in his article does he say (or imply) that "all lefties love islamism". That is a REAL cheap shot.

Edmund Standing
September 16th, 2009
3:09 PM
Steve - 'terror apologist' - which is true. 'all lefties love islamism' - which isn't what the author said. He wrote: 'those who (somehow unashamedly) call themselves part of the left and have allied with Islamists'. If you can't see that both of these things are very real problems, then you wouldn't be of any use in a 'coalition'. It would be like forming a coalition in favour of vegetarianism with someone who doesn't accept that chicken is meat.

Steve
September 16th, 2009
1:09 PM
'terror apologist' ... all lefties love islamism... etc etc. keep this stuff out of your blogs, try to build a coalition, and i might have more time for yor blog. as it is the cheap shots more or less invalidate the good points.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
 
About Focus on Islamism

Focus on Islamism is a blog dedicated to analysing and exposing the modern ideological phenomenon known as Islamism.

Shiraz Maher is a writer and broadcaster.

Alexander Meleagrou-Hitchens is a PhD student at King's College, London.  He has contributed to various online and printed publications including, The Daily Telegraph, Lebanon's Daily Star, Standpoint and NOWLebanon. 

To contact the authors, click here

Recent Blog Posts
Blog List
More Posts
Popular Standpoint topics