You are here:   Columns >  The Outsider's Diary > Selling the Conservative Soul

The sole, accidental, confrontation with reality came when Gordon Brown met Gillian Duffy of Rochdale. Brown was not merely contemptuous of her; what was really striking, to me at any rate, was how little sympathy he had for her. It happened to be Brown caught with the mike on, but it could have been any of them.

If you are a woman of Mrs Duffy's age, living in Rochdale, your world has changed unrecognisably during your lifetime. In the last 20 years alone, Rochdale's ethnic minority population has doubled. In nine of the town's schools, 70 per cent speak English as a foreign language. In another school, where every child is Asian, the figure is 100 per cent.

If there are any jobs to be had in Rochdale, they are very likely to be taken by the imported working-class, rather than the resident one that should have been encouraged to take any jobs on offer. Of all the huge demographic and economic changes that have occurred, none has happened with the consent of Mrs Duffy or anyone else. Nothing she could have done would have stopped it. And yet, like the rest of the British people, Mrs Duffy apparently accepted this wholesale change to her home without recourse to violence or obvious hatred. Just occasionally, mulling on the lack of jobs or prospects for their children and grandchildren and seeing what jobs remain in the former industrial centres going to Eastern European immigrants, such people were simply left to muse, like Mrs Duffy, that "nobody wants to talk about immigration".

One of the most haunting phrases of recent years, which occurred to me again during the Duffy episode, came in a 2006 essay by Roger Scruton in the New Criterion. "The fact is," wrote Scruton, "that the people of Europe are losing their homelands, and therefore losing their place in the world." I would add that not only the people of Europe but along with them many of the ideals of Europe are being made homeless. As we were reminded at this election, even while this is happening the people to whom it is happening cannot comment on it or lament its passing without being dismissed by the people who would rule over them.

The patch of ground of which Cameron has been tenuously entrusted with governorship is being lost to the world and to itself. The only measure of Cameron's life and leadership, and the only judgment that history will care to make, will be whether five years from now that ground is lost a little more or a little less. 

View Full Article

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.