You are here:   Blogs >Peter Whittle > For freedom, choice and liberation, wear the burqa!
Standpoint Blogs
 
 
Peter Whittle
Tuesday 20th July 2010
For freedom, choice and liberation, wear the burqa!

So now Syria has banned the Niqab. What will Western leftists and liberals make of that? An officially secular but largely Muslim country has decided on the ban - like Turkey before it - in order to protect that secularity and discourage a growing Islamic conservatism. I was in Syria quite recently and was told there that the government was seriously concerned by the growth in this grassroots movement. Sure enough, veiled women could be seen everywhere.

And for once I agree with Yasmin Alibhai-Brown,when she writes of her exasperation with Caroline Spelman, the Environment Secretary, who has talked of the freedom and empowerment the veil affords. This comes on the tail of the remarks made by Damian Green, the Immigration minister, that a ban would be 'unBritish'.

Last week I found myself talking twice about the veil - on the BBC's Moral Maze, and then on Sky News.  Such discussions usually take place in a framework which puts great emphasis on the 'choice' involved in wearing the veil. Useful idiots refuse to countenance that most veil wearing is forced. This would of course imply criticism of Muslims, and would mean that liberal feminists would have to break their disgraceful silence and take a stand on the issue.

I am unhappy with the idea of a ban purely because, like all censorship, it symbolises cultural weakness. What we should be doing instead is encouraging our cultural and political leaders to speak out on why our way of life, and our values, are infinitely preferable and worth defending. We must recover from the colossal collapse in cultural confidence which has been exploited and abetted by far too many in our cultural and political elites. What we don't need is the likes of our senior Churchman talking in lofty terms about the inevitability of sharia law, or stupid, ill-informed cabinet ministers spouting ingratiatingly about empowerment.

Tags:
 
Like this article? Share, save or print using the icons below
Delicious   Digg   StumbleUpon   Propeller   Reddit   Magnoliacom   Newsvine   Furl   Facebook   Google   Yahoo   Technorati   Icerocket   Print   Mail   Twitter   
Share/Save
 
 
 
Denis
July 23rd, 2010
12:07 PM
I would agree to a ban. Negotiation won't get women out of this bind. It's time our government stood up to the very defiant brand of Islam that has a disproportionate influence in this country, controls women, wants to expand the application of shari'a, deprives children of a normal education, and much else. It's essential to make it clear who runs this country, and that can only be (in this context) by drawing a line across what is and what is not acceptable behaviour in public, by defining what Muslims may and may not do, according to our laws, not theirs. The burqa and niqab are in utter defiance of any hope for integration. They snark in the face of everyone else and act as a barrier to any real communication. They diminish Muslim women and deny them a proper part in British society. They have no justification in normal Islamic fiqh. Even the more normal hijab worries me, because use of it has grown up because of rising levels of political Islam and because traditionalist Islam that should have died out generations ago (and was almost dead in Iran, Egypt, Turkey, Syria, and some other countries) has been reinforced for young girls of the present generation. The French have been much more sensible than we in dealing with this. AC secular society has to be just that. All forms of veiling take place within the context of fatwas that dictate inferiority for women, in marriage, divorce, child custody, inheritance, employment, participation in the arts and sports, and more. All these restrictions are, in some sense, illegal under British law, but we sit back and do nothing to enforce proper equality. Let's start with the burqa and niqab.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
 
About Peter Whittle

Peter Whittle is director of the New Culture Forum and author of Look at Me: Celebrating the Self in Modern Britain, Private Views: Voices from the Front Line of British Culture and, most recently, Monarchy Matters.

Recent Blog Posts
Blog List
More Posts
Popular Standpoint topics