You are here:   Civilisation >  Screen > Murder Most Mundane

Intelligence without make-up: Sofie Gråbøl as detective Sarah Lund in "The Killing" 

Imagine the future. Not your preferred utopia or feared dystopia but what you expect Britain to look like in 30 years. It is not idiotic to think that if current trends continue, Britain, much of the rest of Europe, Australia and North and South America will be more Scandinavian. We will accept the equality of women and women in positions of power. We will be more socially egalitarian, or if inequalities in wealth are still as great as they are now, then the class distinctions left by the old aristocracy will be less important. Society will enforce liberalism with more rules and codes. I know people bemoan our existing PC culture, but I doubt their sincerity because no man is a free-marketeer when his boss unfairly dismisses him, and no woman complains about "political correctness gone mad" when she is the victim of sexual harassment. Modern people want transparent and accountable systems that protect their rights. Even if they do not realise it, even if they think they do not want it, they are groping towards the Scandinavian model.

"If current trends continue" are the four most treacherous words in sociology. Current trends have a habit of stopping in their tracks and heading off in new directions. But the belief that Scandinavia represents a possible future helps to explain the phenomenal success of its crime fiction. Stieg Larsson's Millennium trilogy has sold almost 30 million copies. British television has shown three versions of Henning Mankell's Wallander novels. Now BBC4 is offering us Danish television's thriller The Killing, the first drama from Europe that can compete with the best of American TV.

Showing the dark side of supposedly ordered societies is a trick used by 1940s  film noir writers and the authors of English country-house murders, although I think it is fair to say that this is the first and last similarity between them. Scandinavian crime is no different. Mankell's Kurt Wallander reflects: "The Sweden that was his, the country he had grown up in, that was built after the war, was not as solid as they had thought. Under the surface was quagmire." 

But for all the corruption shown, the appeal of Scandinavian crime lies in its moral assumptions, which its writers take for granted but outsiders find startlingly modern, even exotic.

Larsson's Millennium trilogy ends patly with everyone who runs Sweden from the prime minister downwards turning on the misogynists in their midst as they remember that they are good social democrats who must respect fundamental rights.  More satisfyingly, The Killing has a female lead unlike any other I have seen. 

The best way to describe Sofie Gråbøl, who plays detective Sarah Lund, is to list what she is not. She is not a glamorous film star. Neither is she the "feisty" heroine, beloved by television and film executives alike, who is just as tough as the men she works with. Nor is she a feminist heroine, like DCI Tennyson in Prime Suspect, who must cope with the resentments of her male colleagues. True, her deputy is a tough guy, whose willingness to bend the rules contrasts with her adherence to the letter of the law. But what looks like standard male/female typecasting breaks down as the series moves on. Lund operates in a society where a woman in a position of power is unexceptional. As a result, she can be something extraordinary in contemporary drama, an intelligent middle-aged woman who has no time to put on make-up or change her outfit because she is trying to solve the rape and murder of a teenage girl. Instead of worrying about her gender, the camera watches Lund as she quietly notices small details, and becomes ever more preoccupied as the pressure on her builds.

View Full Article

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.